How Midmarket IT Leaders Can Turn MSP Automation Savings Into Lower Bills
AI is changing the economics of managed services. Midmarket IT leaders heading into renewal have an opportunity to make sure some of those efficiency gains reach their own invoices.
(Image: Getty)
For many IT leaders, the conversation around AI has moved from whether to adopt it to how much they should pay for AI and AI-enabled services. Forrester’s 2027 AI spending predictions show that AI will take one dollar in five of business technology spending next year, and the firm expects services spending to see the biggest cuts as AI lowers the cost of delivering consulting and managed services.
Managed service providers (MSPs) now use AI to automate, monitor and resolve routine issues with far less human intervention, and MES Computing reported earlier this year that IT leaders were beginning to ask whether those efficiency gains were being passed on to them or absorbed by their MSPs.
Because providers realize those savings first, the question for buyers heading into renewal is how to make sure some of that efficiency shows up on their own invoices.
Where The Renewal Conversation Should Begin
Tom Collins, a senior consultant at IDC, writes that an MSP’s per-unit costs fall as it deploys AI, and he urges buyers to ask at renewal how those gains will be shared. This point was also echoed by John Grosshans, president of field operations at AI-powered observability company LogicMonitor.
“AI gives service providers an opportunity to fundamentally change the economics of managed IT, but the real question for customers is what they’re getting in return,” Grosshans told MES Computing. He believes renewals should start with CIOs asking their MSPs to show where automation reduces manual work and how those efficiencies improve service delivery.
However, MSPs are under no obligation to disclose the profit margins they now make from automating work their staff once handled, and Corey Nachreiner, CISO at cybersecurity company WatchGuard, believes buyers gain little by pressing for that information.
“Don’t ask how much of the work is automated. You will get a number you cannot verify, cannot act on, and that frankly isn’t your business,” Nachreiner told MES Computing via email.
Instead, the more useful questions should focus on the outcomes the provider delivers as those are the results a buyer can measure and bring to the negotiating table.
Getting Efficiency Onto The Invoice
Pricing tied to users, devices or the volume of work may no longer reflect the value being delivered once AI takes on more of the operational load, Grosshans argues. He wants midmarket IT buyers to push for a model that pairs predictable fees with commitments on outcomes such as faster incident resolution and improved availability.
“The goal shouldn’t be to reward MSPs for performing more tasks. It should be to reward them for delivering better results,” he said.
Frank Meltke, CEO of contraco, a digital transformation consultancy, sees a middle path for most midmarket buyers, one that lets them share in the savings without giving up predictable costs.
“Keep a base fee for availability and accountability, and price the high-volume, repetitive work per resolved unit, with a unit price that steps down each year as automation rises. The step-down is where the savings are shared, and it is written into the contract instead of being negotiated again at every renewal," Meltke advised.
However, price reductions of this kind will not apply evenly across every service, and knowing where automation reduces costs most gives buyers a clearer sense of where to push when their 2027 renewals arrive. Routine work such as first-line support, alert triage, event correlation and initial investigation is becoming increasingly automated, and Grosshans believes “customers should expect providers to deliver those services more efficiently.”
Work that depends on judgment, such as deciding whether it is safe to restart a service that several critical applications depend on, still needs an experienced engineer and can justify a higher fee. If buyers are asked to pay that premium, they have good reason to check that the expertise behind it is still there. Meltke suggests they begin by asking who checks the AI’s work before it takes effect. “If the answer is nobody, the buyer is paying a premium for human expertise in a service that no longer contains any.”
For IT leaders heading into renewal, that means separating automatable work from services that still require specialized expertise, identifying the outcomes the MSP is contractually accountable for, and determining how efficiency gains will affect unit pricing over the life of the agreement. The objective is not simply to demand a lower bill because the provider uses AI, but to make sure the pricing model still reflects the work performed and the value delivered.
Until more contracts change, providers will continue to benefit most from the efficiency that automation brings. The coming renewal cycle gives midmarket buyers a timely opportunity to make sure some of those gains reach their own invoices.